Resolved Question
Should I go for an ECN or Market Maker?
over 2 years ago
Best Answer - Chosen by Voters
A market maker basically reduces transaction costs and increases liquidity, making it easy for its clients to trade. The efforts of market makers are compensated through the bid/ask spread they themselves set. In addition, these market makers take the opposite side of their clients’ trade. Whenever their clients sell, they must buy from their client and vice-versa. There are exceptions though. Sometimes, these market makers try to cover orders by matching the initial buy/sell order with another client. An electronics commission network (ECN) broker, on the other hand, derives currency prices from several sources such as banks, market makers and other traders and firms connected to the ECN. Unlike market makers, ECN brokers do not set prices themselves and therefore, they generally offer the best bid/ask quotes for their clients. Furthermore, ECN broker prices are not fixed and change depending on a currencies trading activity. These firms make money through charging their customers a fixed commission per trade. There are pros and cons for both types of brokers mentioned and there certainly isn’t a “better” one. It all depends on the individual traders on what is better suited for him or her.
over 2 years ago
Answers (1)
The best thing you could do is to make a thorough comparison. Start on the amount of commission charges. If ECN would take a fraction off your gains, then it would be better to go to Market Maker. Also, keep in mind that ECN doesn't have fixed spreads; thus the spread is sometimes wider or narrower.
over 2 years ago
* You must be logged in to add comments. Sign In or Join Askpips.com.
Resolved Questions in Brokers
- How do market makers make money?
- What is the difference between micro and a mini account?
- If I deposit in a broker amounting for example $5000, can I lose more than that amount?
- Does MetaTrader allow opening of multiple accounts?
- Is there a broker who doesn’t charge clients in a form of “pips per trade”?

* You must be logged in to add comments. Sign In or Join Askpips.com.